Party Games
How to play Would You Rather?
Choose between two hypothetical options and explain your preference. This is a conversation game without a required correct answer.
What you need
Two or more participants and age-appropriate two-option prompts
Set up the game
- Choose a host or rotate question readers. Agree that anyone may pass and that answers are hypothetical rather than promises to do something.
- Use a spoken-answer circle for this house format. Allow everyone to choose before discussing reasons.
Playing Would You Rather?
- Read one clear question containing two alternatives. Clarify shared assumptions before people commit.
- Everyone chooses an option or passes. Invite a short reason without treating the majority answer as correct.
- Rotate readers and continue for an agreed number of prompts or time. No points, elimination or final winner are required.
Different choices, equally valid reasons
Would you rather explore an underwater city or a town in the clouds? One player prefers sea life; another dislikes deep water. There is no factual scoring key that makes one preference a winning answer.
Make prompts specific enough to discuss
“Fly or be invisible?” leaves important assumptions open. Try “Would you rather fly slowly for ten minutes each day or become invisible for ten minutes each day?” Both sides now have the same limit, and the discussion can focus on how each ability would be used. Keep prompts away from real humiliations or private family matters.
Beginner decisions
- Use choices with a real tradeoff rather than one obviously unpleasant option.
Common rule mix-ups
- Turning a hypothetical answer into a dare.
- Changing an option after hearing another player’s reasoning.
Questions about this game
Is it an official boxed game?
This guide covers a spoken traditional format, not a specific commercial product.
Can people change their minds?
Yes in this discussion format; hearing a good reason is part of the activity.
Sources and edition notes
Unscored spoken house format. The Scouts source demonstrates choosing and discussing two alternatives in a themed educational activity; its equipment and homelessness lesson are not required here.
Sources and stated format checked October 14, 2026. This records a document check, not a claim of hands-on testing.
Report a rule or edition correction →